Your seller signed, then stopped answering, missed closing, or found a higher offer. If you want the property rather than your deposit back, the court remedy is specific performance. This page covers that lawsuit. What to do in the first days after a missed closing is in what to do when a seller won’t close; the full list of remedies for a breach, including rescission, is in seller breach of a real estate contract. Both sit under the main guide, what to do when your seller won’t perform.
What specific performance is
Cornell’s Legal Information Institute defines specific performance as a contractual remedy in which a court orders a party to fulfill their obligations “as closely as possible to what was promised in the contract, rather than simply paying damages” (LII). It is “often applied when monetary damages are inadequate,” and is most common in cases involving real property and rare items.
For a home purchase, that means a judge orders the seller to deed you the property on the contract’s terms, and you pay the contract price. The Texas Supreme Court calls it “an equitable remedy that may be awarded for breach of contract” (Pathfinder, 2019). “May” is the operative word: it is the court’s call, not an automatic result of a breach. There is a short definition in the glossary entry for specific performance.
Why courts treat land as unique
Money damages work when you can buy the same thing elsewhere. A particular lot or house can’t be bought elsewhere, so the law has long assumed money may fall short. Some states write that into statute. Montana’s code says: “It is to be presumed that the breach of an agreement to transfer real property cannot be adequately relieved by pecuniary compensation” (MCA 27-1-419). Other states reach the result through court decisions. A presumption is a starting point, not a guarantee, and how strong it is varies by state. We haven’t checked every state; ask an attorney where your property sits.
What a buyer generally has to show
The details vary by state and by your contract. These are the common requirements, with the sources we read:
| Requirement | What it means in practice | Source |
|---|---|---|
| A valid contract | A signed purchase contract that the court finds valid and enforceable. | Breach-of-contract elements, Pathfinder (Tex. 2019) |
| The seller breached | The seller failed to perform as the contract required: refused to sign the deed, missed closing, sold or tried to sell elsewhere. | Pathfinder; TREC 20-19 ¶15 (“If Seller fails to comply with this contract, Seller will be in default”) |
| You were ready, willing and able | You did your part and could have closed: deposit made, deadlines met, the money to pay the price. Texas requires proof of this “at all relevant times”; a contested question goes to the jury. | Pathfinder, citing DiGiuseppe v. Lawler (Tex. 2008) |
| You performed your conditions | Montana bars specific performance for a party who hasn’t “fully and fairly performed all the conditions precedent,” unless the shortfall is immaterial or can be fully compensated. | MCA 27-1-416 |
| Fair to enforce against the seller | Montana won’t compel a party who got inadequate consideration, where it isn’t just and reasonable, or whose assent came from misrepresentation or mistake. Other states have their own versions of these defenses. | MCA 27-1-415 |
One Texas case is worth knowing. In DiGiuseppe v. Lawler, the contract said the buyer could “seek to enforce specific performance.” The Texas Supreme Court, describing that case in 2019, said the clause left open “the possibility that he may seek to enforce it, but be unable to do so”: the buyer still had to prove he was ready, willing and able, and didn’t (Pathfinder, 2019). A remedies clause gives you the right to ask, not the result.
What your contract says about it
Start with the default paragraph. In the Texas Real Estate Commission’s standard resale contract, paragraph 15 says that if the seller fails to comply, the buyer may “(a) enforce specific performance, seek such other relief as may be provided by law, or both, or (b) terminate this contract and receive the earnest money, thereby releasing both parties from this contract” (TREC form 20-19, dated 05-04-2026). The same form sends unresolved disputes to mediation but says that “does not preclude a party from seeking equitable relief from a court” (¶16), and lets the party who prevails in a legal proceeding recover reasonable attorney’s fees and costs (¶17).
Investor and custom contracts often aren’t on the TREC form. Read your own default, remedies, mediation and attorney’s-fees clauses, because they may word the buyer’s options differently or limit them.
Specific performance, damages, or terminate and take the deposit
Three ways a buyer’s side of a seller default usually goes. The contract column quotes the TREC resale form; yours may differ. The full remedies list, including rescission, is on seller breach of a real estate contract.
| Route | What you’re asking for | Lawsuit? | What you give up | TREC 20-19 ¶15 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Specific performance | The property itself, at the contract price, by court order. | Yes. A lis pendens can be recorded while it’s pending (Texas §12.007). | Time and legal fees; you must stay ready to close. Ask an attorney for an estimate. | “enforce specific performance” |
| Damages | Money for losses the breach caused. You don’t get the property. | Yes, unless the seller settles. | The property. What you can recover depends on your contract and state law. | “seek such other relief as may be provided by law, or both” |
| Terminate, get the earnest money back | Your deposit back and an end to the deal. | Usually not. The form has a written-demand process with the escrow agent (¶18C). | The contract: on the TREC form this releases both parties. | “terminate this contract and receive the earnest money” |
Wholesalers and assignees
“Can a wholesaler sue the seller for specific performance if the seller refuses to close?” If you are the buyer named on the contract, you are the party who would sue, and the same requirements apply. Expect the seller to test whether you were ready, willing and able to pay the price yourself or through the buyer you planned to assign to. How a court looks at that is a question for your attorney.
If you already assigned the contract, whether you, your assignee or both can sue depends on the contract’s assignment terms, the assignment itself and state law. The TREC resale form has no assignment paragraph, so in Texas it usually turns on what the parties added. We won’t generalize further; ask a real-estate attorney. For the assignment side of protecting a deal, see how to protect your wholesale assignment.
A Texas trap for buyer-only memorandums. If you recorded a memorandum signed only by you on a single-family house, duplex to fourplex, or condo on or after September 1, 2025, and didn’t send the certified-mail notice and record the certificate of mailing, then “the sole remedy available in an action brought to enforce a person’s rights asserted under the unilateral memorandum of contract … is money damages” (Property Code §12.020(k)(4)). Tell your attorney about any memorandum you’ve filed. The rules are in the Texas §12.020 guide.
How a lis pendens fits once the suit is filed
A lis pendens is recorded notice that a lawsuit is pending. Texas law, read on the legislature’s site on October 29, 2026:
- When: during an action involving title to real property or the establishment of an interest in it, “a party to the action who is seeking affirmative relief” may record one in each county where the property sits (§12.007(a)).
- What it says: the case style and number, the court, the parties, the kind of proceeding and a description of the property, signed by the party or their attorney (§12.007(b)).
- Service: a copy goes to each party with an interest in the property no later than the third day after filing (§12.007(d)).
- Effect: it is “notice to the world of its contents” once recorded and indexed. Without one, a transfer by a party to a buyer who pays value and has no actual or constructive notice of the suit is effective, even if the judgment goes against the seller (§13.004).
- Expunction: a court must order it expunged if the pleading has no real property claim, the claimant can’t show the claim’s probable validity by a preponderance of the evidence, or the copies weren’t served (§12.0071).
That is why your attorney, not you, decides whether to record one. Other states have their own lis pendens statutes. The side-by-side is in memorandum of contract vs. lis pendens.
Why notice on the record matters before any suit
A lis pendens exists only once a suit is filed. Between a missed closing and a filed lawsuit there can be days or weeks of demand letters, mediation and finding a lawyer. During that gap the seller can try to sign with someone else, and §13.004 shows why notice matters: in Texas, without a recorded lis pendens, a transfer to a buyer who pays value and has no actual or constructive notice of the suit can stand even if you win.
A recorded memorandum of contract puts your contract in the public record before any suit. In Texas, a properly recorded instrument is “notice to all persons of the existence of the instrument” (Property Code §13.002), so a title search for a later buyer or lender turns it up. It doesn’t make the seller close, doesn’t stop a sale and doesn’t replace a lawsuit. What it does is keep your contract visible while you and your attorney decide.
Costs and timelines
We don’t publish cost or time estimates for a specific performance suit: they depend on the attorney, the court’s docket, and whether the seller settles or fights. Ask a real-estate attorney for an estimate. Useful questions:
- How do you bill for this kind of case, and what would a realistic range look like for mine?
- Does my contract’s mediation clause apply first, and does its attorney’s-fees clause help or hurt me?
- How long do cases like this take in the county where the property is?
- Should we record a lis pendens, and when?
- What happens to my earnest money while the case runs?
- If I’m a wholesaler, how will I show I was ready, willing and able to close?
While you sort out the dispute
A recorded memorandum of contract puts later buyers and lenders on notice that your contract exists. In Texas, a properly recorded instrument is notice to all persons (§13.002); a memorandum signed only by the buyer on a 1–4 family home or condo also needs the certified-mail notice and recorded certificate of mailing (§12.020). It doesn’t stop a sale, force the seller to close, or replace a lawsuit. Jurably’s $199 filing includes the online notary session and county fees (all of them in Texas, up to $42 elsewhere), in 14 states; in Texas it sends the §12.020 notice and records the certificate of mailing.
Disclosure: Jurably is our service. It’s a self-help filing service, not a law firm.
Questions people ask
What is specific performance in real estate?
It is a court order that makes a party do what the contract promised, here, that the seller complete the sale, instead of only paying damages (Cornell LII). Courts use it most often for real property, because money may not replace a particular piece of land. It comes through a lawsuit, so talk to a real-estate attorney.
Can I sue a seller for specific performance if they refuse to close?
A buyer can ask a court for it. Whether a court grants it depends on your contract, your facts and your state’s law. In Texas, the Supreme Court has said a party seeking specific performance must plead and prove that, at all relevant times, it was ready, willing, and able to perform (Pathfinder Oil & Gas v. Great Western Drilling, 2019). Talk to a real-estate attorney before you act.
Can a real estate wholesaler sue the seller for specific performance?
If you are the buyer on the contract, you are the party who would sue, and the same requirements apply, including showing you were ready, willing and able to perform. If you already assigned the contract, whether you or your assignee can sue depends on the contract’s assignment terms and state law. In Texas, a buyer-only memorandum on a 1–4 family home or condo filed without the §12.020 notice limits the remedy in an action to enforce rights asserted under it to money damages. Ask a real-estate attorney.
Do I need a lis pendens to sue for specific performance?
No. A lis pendens is a notice recorded once a suit is pending, not a requirement to sue. In Texas, a party seeking affirmative relief in an action involving title to, or an interest in, real property may record one and must serve a copy on each party with an interest in the property within three days (Property Code §12.007). Your attorney decides whether to file one.
If I take my earnest money back, can I still sue for specific performance?
Under the standard Texas resale contract (TREC form 20-19, paragraph 15), a buyer facing a seller default chooses between enforcing specific performance (and other relief allowed by law) or terminating and receiving the earnest money, “thereby releasing both parties from this contract.” Other contracts word this differently. Don’t sign an earnest-money release until an attorney has read your contract.
How much does a specific performance lawsuit cost, and how long does it take?
We don’t publish estimates, because they depend on the attorney, the court and how hard the seller fights. Ask a real-estate attorney for an estimate of fees and timeline. Check your contract for a mediation clause and an attorney’s-fees clause: the TREC resale form has both (paragraphs 16 and 17).
Does a recorded memorandum of contract replace a specific performance suit?
No. A memorandum doesn’t make the seller close and doesn’t stop a sale. It puts the contract in the public record: in Texas, a properly recorded instrument is notice to all persons of its existence (Property Code §13.002). That matters for any later buyer or lender while you and your attorney decide whether to sue.
General information for real-estate buyers and investors, not legal advice. Jurably is a self-help filing service, not a law firm, and doesn’t represent you or judge your deal. For a specific performance claim, talk to a real-estate attorney licensed in your state.
What Jurably is: self-service forms that you complete, review and approve yourself, plus a paid administrative service that coordinates the online notary, submits the document to the county for recording and handles any mailing the state requires. Jurably is not a law firm, does not give legal advice and is no substitute for an attorney. If you have a question about your rights or about anything legal, contact an attorney.
State-by-state guides
Recording rules and county pages for the states this guide covers:
Sources
Every fact above was checked against these on October 29, 2026. Researched and drafted with AI assistance; each figure was compared with its source before publishing.
- Cornell Law School, Legal Information Institute: specific performance (definition): law.cornell.edu
- Supreme Court of Texas, Pathfinder Oil & Gas v. Great Western Drilling, No. 18-0186 (May 24, 2019): txcourts.gov
- Montana Code 27-1-419: breach of an agreement to transfer real property presumed not adequately relieved by money: leg.mt.gov
- Montana Code 27-1-416: parties who cannot obtain specific performance: leg.mt.gov
- Montana Code 27-1-415: parties who cannot be compelled to perform: leg.mt.gov
- TREC One to Four Family Residential Contract (Resale), form 20-19, ¶15 Default, ¶16 Mediation, ¶17 Attorney’s Fees, ¶18 Escrow: trec.texas.gov
- Texas Property Code §12.007: lis pendens: tcss.legis.texas.gov
- Texas Property Code §12.0071: motion to expunge a lis pendens: tcss.legis.texas.gov
- Texas Property Code §13.004: effect of recording a lis pendens: tcss.legis.texas.gov
- Texas Property Code §13.002: a recorded instrument is notice to all persons: tcss.legis.texas.gov
- Texas Property Code §12.020: unilateral memorandum of contract on residential property: tcss.legis.texas.gov