Owner or filer: talk to an attorney first
If you own the property and are thinking about suing, a real-estate attorney in your state can tell you which claim fits and what proof you’d need. If you filed the memorandum and an owner is threatening a claim, talk to one before you answer, release or refuse. This page is general information, not legal advice, and we’ve verified the law only for the states named on it.
A memorandum of contract is a short recorded notice that a buyer has a contract on a property. Once recorded it is notice to later buyers and lenders (in Texas, Property Code §13.002), which is why it shows up on a title commitment. It is exactly the kind of document slander-of-title claims are about. This page covers both sides: the owner asking whether they can sue, and the filer asking whether a memorandum can expose them.
The elements of slander of title, by state
Slander of title is mostly court-made law, so the elements come from appellate opinions. Three we read on the courts’ own sites on October 29, 2026:
| State | What the owner must prove | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Texas | A “false and malicious statement made in disparagement of a person’s title to property which causes special damages.” Damages aren’t presumed; special damages exist when the owner shows the loss of a specific, pending sale that the slander frustrated. | Supreme Court of Texas, Allen-Pieroni v. Pieroni, No. 16-0900 (2017) |
| Ohio | Four: (1) publication of a slanderous statement disparaging the claimant’s title; (2) the statement was false; (3) it was made with malice or reckless disregard of its falsity; (4) it caused actual or special damages. The court describes the tort as “generally” committed “by wrongfully recording an unfounded claim.” | Ohio Court of Appeals, 8th District, 2024-Ohio-1280 |
| Iowa | Five, proved by a preponderance of the evidence: (1) uttering and publication of slanderous words; (2) falsity; (3) malice; (4) special damages; (5) the owner’s estate or interest in the property. | Iowa Court of Appeals, Toney v. Parker, No. 23-1830 (2025) |
In other states the elements may differ. Ask an attorney in your state rather than assuming one of these lists applies.
Special damages are where claims fail
Unlike other defamation claims, the owner always has to prove a money loss. Both of the recent opinions we read reversed an award on that point:
- Texas, 2017. An ex-spouse recorded an abstract of judgment against the owner’s house, and his pending sale fell through after she refused to release the lien. The trial court awarded his lost equity: the contract price minus his mortgage balance. The Supreme Court of Texas said that is the wrong measure. When the owner still has the property, damages are generally the contract price minus the property’s market value at trial with the cloud removed, and the owner had offered no evidence of that value (No. 16-0900).
- Iowa, 2025. A tenant recorded a lifetime lease with an option to purchase, which the trial court found was forged, after the owners’ sale fell through over his claim. The Court of Appeals still reversed the slander-of-title award, because the owners offered no appraisal, comparable sales or other evidence of market value (Toney v. Parker).
Statutes for false recorded documents
Several states don’t leave it to the common-law claim. Their statutes target false or groundless recorded documents directly and set a minimum recovery, so the owner isn’t limited to proving a lost sale. We read each one on the official code site on October 29, 2026. We haven’t verified the other states.
| Route | Who brings it | What has to be shown | What the owner can recover | What documents it reaches |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Slander of title (court-made claim) Texas, Ohio and Iowa opinions above | The owner | A false statement about title, made with malice (Ohio: or reckless disregard), that caused a provable money loss. | Special (economic) damages. In Texas, when the owner still has the property, generally the lost contract price minus the market value at trial with the cloud removed. No statutory minimum. | Any false statement disparaging title; recording a document is the usual way it happens. |
| Texas: fraudulent lien or claim Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code §12.002 | A person who owns an interest in the property, plus the attorney general and other government attorneys (§12.003) | The filer knew the document was a fraudulent lien or claim, meant it to have legal effect, and meant to cause financial injury, physical injury or mental anguish. | $10,000 or actual damages, whichever is greater, plus court costs, reasonable attorney’s fees and exemplary damages. | A fraudulent “lien or claim against real … property or an interest in” it. The text isn’t limited to liens, and it doesn’t mention memorandums. |
| Texas: motion for judicial review Gov’t Code §51.903 | The owner, by a verified motion to the district clerk | Reason to believe the document is fraudulent as defined in §51.901(c)(2). A judge may decide from the document alone, without a hearing. | No money. A recorded finding of fact and conclusion of law. No district clerk filing fee and no fee to record the finding. | A “document purporting to create a lien or a claim against” real property or an interest in it. The motion doesn’t decide the parties’ underlying claim. |
| Colorado: groundless recorded document C.R.S. 38-35-109(3) | The owner | The filer knew or had reason to know the document was forged, groundless, materially false or otherwise invalid; or a person it benefits willfully refused to release it on the owner’s request. | $1,000 or actual damages, whichever is greater, plus reasonable attorney fees. | Any document “purporting to convey, encumber, create a lien against, or otherwise affect the title to real property.” |
| Arizona: false documents A.R.S. §33-420 | The owner or beneficial title holder | Recording a claim the filer knew or had reason to know was forged, groundless, materially false or otherwise invalid (A); or, for a person named in it who knows that, wilfully refusing to release or correct it within 20 days of the owner’s written request (C). | (A): $5,000 or treble actual damages, whichever is greater. (C): $1,000 or treble actual damages. Both plus attorney fees and costs. Recording one is also a class 5 felony (E). | A document asserting a claim to “an interest in, or a lien or encumbrance against, real property.” One not authorized by statute, judgment or other specific legal authority is presumed groundless (D). |
| Georgia: false or forged instrument O.C.G.A. §51-9-12 | The owner | The person knowingly recorded a false or forged deed or other instrument. | Actual damages or $5,000, whichever is greater, plus costs including reasonable attorney’s fees. | An instrument “purporting to convey” or “purporting to encumber” the owner’s interest. The statute doesn’t mention memorandums. |
Georgia’s section is cited to House Bill 1292 (2024), which added it, as signed and posted on the governor’s site; we read the September 2026 archived copy of that official page.
Texas Chapter 12 and memorandums. The chapter’s title says “fraudulent lien or claim”, and its liability section reaches a fraudulent “claim against real or personal property or an interest in real or personal property” (§12.002(a)). So its text isn’t limited to liens, but it never mentions memorandums, and liability needs knowledge, intent to give the document legal effect, and intent to cause injury. Separately, Texas presumes a document asserting a claim to an interest in real property fraudulent if, among other things, it wasn’t created by the owner’s express or implied consent or agreement (Gov’t Code §51.901(c)(2)). The code doesn’t say how that applies to a buyer-only memorandum of a contract the owner signed. A court decides.
If you own the property: can you sue?
Suing is one route, and usually not the first. If you need the memorandum off the title before a sale or refinance, a lawsuit is slow. In order:
- Ask for a release, in writing. Name the memorandum’s recording number and date. In Arizona, a person named in a document who knows it is groundless and wilfully refuses to release or correct it within 20 days of your written request becomes liable for at least $1,000 or treble damages (§33-420(C)); in Colorado, a person benefited by a groundless document who willfully refuses to release it on your request carries the same liability as the person who recorded it (38-35-109(3)).
- Texas: the owner affidavit. If the property is a house, duplex to fourplex or condo and only the buyer signed the memorandum, you can record an owner’s affidavit and certificate of mailing that releases it, unless the filer records a contradicting affidavit within 45 days (Property Code §12.020). If you believe the document is fraudulent, you can also ask a district judge to review it by verified motion, with no filing fee (Gov’t Code §51.903).
- A court action. Quiet title, slander of title or the state statute in the table above. An attorney can tell you which fits.
Before any of that, ask yourself the falsity question honestly. If you signed a purchase contract with the filer and it hasn’t ended, the memorandum may be accurate, and a claim built on it being false may not hold up. If you did sign, the cloud-on-title guide explains what the memorandum does to your title, and the owner’s guide to removing a memorandum covers the release routes in Texas, Colorado and Arizona.
If you filed the memorandum: how to stay clear
Every claim and statute on this page turns on a document that is false, groundless or kept on record in bad faith. A memorandum that stays true, and comes off record when the deal ends, is the opposite of what they target. Three habits do most of the work:
- Record only on a real, signed contract, and describe it accurately. No memorandum before the seller signs, none on a “handshake” deal, and no terms in it that the contract doesn’t contain. Colorado and Arizona both reach a recorded document that “contains a material misstatement or false claim” (38-35-109(3), §33-420(A)).
- Release it when the contract ends. Closed, cancelled, expired or terminated: record a release promptly, and answer a written release request well inside Arizona’s 20 days. The release guide covers how. If the seller says the deal is off and you disagree, read what to do when a seller demands you remove the memorandum, and talk to an attorney before you refuse.
- In Texas, follow §12.020. For a memorandum signed only by the buyer on a house, duplex to fourplex or condo, give the county clerk your mailing address and a certificate of mailing to record with it, and no later than the filing date send the owner a copy and a letter by certified or registered mail, return receipt requested, to the property address and the owner’s other listed addresses (§12.020(b)). If the owner then records a release affidavit and you don’t file a contradicting affidavit within 45 days, buyers and lenders can rely on the release, and the only remedy in a suit to enforce the rights the memorandum asserts is money damages (§12.020(f)(2)). The Texas §12.020 guide walks through it.
State recording rules for the statutes above: Arizona, Colorado, Georgia and Texas.
Texas owner? Our Owner Release page runs the §12.020 affidavit process. Disclosure: Jurably is our service. It’s a self-help filing service, not a law firm.
Questions people ask
What is slander of title?
A lawsuit over a false statement that casts doubt on someone’s title to property. The Supreme Court of Texas defines it as a “false and malicious statement made in disparagement of a person’s title to property which causes special damages” (Allen-Pieroni v. Pieroni, 2017). It usually involves a recorded document, and the owner has to prove an actual money loss.
What are the elements of slander of title?
They vary by state. Iowa’s Court of Appeals lists five: publication of slanderous words, falsity, malice, special damages, and the owner’s interest in the property (Toney v. Parker, 2025). Ohio’s Eighth District lists four: publication, falsity, malice or reckless disregard of falsity, and actual or special damages (2024-Ohio-1280). Texas requires a false and malicious statement that causes special damages, usually the loss of a specific, pending sale.
Can a memorandum of contract get me sued for slander of title?
Anyone can file a lawsuit; the question is whether the claim holds up. Slander of title needs a false statement made with malice and a proven money loss. A memorandum that accurately describes a real, signed contract that is still in force states something true. The risk comes from recording one with no contract behind it, misstating the contract, or leaving it on record after the contract ends. Arizona, Colorado, Georgia and Texas also have statutes aimed at false recorded documents. Talk to a real-estate attorney about your facts.
Someone recorded a memorandum on my house. Can I sue them?
Possibly, but a lawsuit is usually the last step. Ask the filer in writing to record a release first. In Arizona, a person named in the document who knows it is groundless and wilfully ignores that written request for 20 days becomes liable under §33-420(C). In Texas, a buyer-only memorandum on a house, duplex to fourplex or condo can be released by the owner’s own affidavit under Property Code §12.020. Whether to sue, and under which claim, is a question for a real-estate attorney in your state.
Is a memorandum of contract a fraudulent lien under Texas Chapter 12?
Chapter 12 doesn’t mention memorandums. It covers a fraudulent “lien or claim against real or personal property or an interest in” property, so its text isn’t limited to liens. Liability requires that the filer knew the document was fraudulent, meant it to have legal effect, and meant to cause injury (§12.002(a)). Whether a particular memorandum fits is for a court to decide.
What damages can an owner recover for slander of title?
Special damages, meaning economic loss the owner proves. In Texas, when the owner still has the property, the measure is generally the lost contract price minus the property’s market value at trial with the cloud removed; the seller’s lost profit over the mortgage balance is not the measure (Allen-Pieroni, 2017). In Iowa an award was reversed because the owners offered no evidence of market value (Toney v. Parker, 2025). The false-document statutes set minimums instead: $10,000 in Texas Chapter 12, $5,000 in Arizona and Georgia, $1,000 in Colorado.
State-by-state guides
Recording rules and county pages for the states this guide covers:
- how deed recording works in Texas· filing a memorandum of contract in Texas
- Arizona deed recording, county by county· Arizona memorandum of contract rules and fees
- Ohio county recorders and recording fees· recording a memorandum in Ohio
- how deed recording works in Colorado· filing a memorandum of contract in Colorado
- Iowa deed recording, county by county· Iowa memorandum of contract rules and fees
- Georgia county recorders and recording fees· recording a memorandum in Georgia
Sources
Every fact above was checked against these on October 29, 2026. Researched and drafted with AI assistance; each figure was compared with its source before publishing.
- Supreme Court of Texas, Allen-Pieroni v. Pieroni, No. 16-0900 (Dec. 15, 2017): definition, special damages, measure of damages: txcourts.gov
- Ohio Court of Appeals, 8th District, North Royalton Court Condo Owners’ Assn. v. Stadul, 2024-Ohio-1280: elements: supremecourt.ohio.gov
- Iowa Court of Appeals, Toney v. Parker, No. 23-1830 (July 23, 2025): elements; award reversed for no market-value evidence: iowacourts.gov
- Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code chapter 12 (§12.002 liability, §12.003 who may sue, §12.004 venue): tcss.legis.texas.gov
- Texas Government Code §51.901 (when a document is presumed fraudulent): tcss.legis.texas.gov
- Texas Government Code §51.903 (motion for judicial review; no filing fee): tcss.legis.texas.gov
- Texas Property Code §12.020 (unilateral memorandum of contract on residential property): tcss.legis.texas.gov
- Texas Property Code §13.002 (a recorded instrument is notice to all persons): tcss.legis.texas.gov
- Colorado C.R.S. title 38 (38-35-109(3) liability for groundless documents): olls.info
- Arizona A.R.S. §33-420 (false documents; liability; special action; felony): azleg.gov
- Georgia HB 1292 (2024) as signed, adding O.C.G.A. §51-9-12 (archived copy of gov.georgia.gov): web.archive.org